$12,000 postmaster’s provisional highlights Regency-Superior’s APS Stampshow sale

May 3, 2021, 7 AM

By Matthew Healey, New York Correspondent

Here is one of four recent auctions we are recapping in our latest U.S. Auction Roundup:

St. Louis-based Regency-Superiors Aug. 6-7 sale at APS Stampshow opened with some early postmasters’ provisional stamps, locally made in the 1840s before the first nationwide U.S. stamp issue. Most surviving provisionals are nothing but crude handstamps, and very rare, although in a handful of larger cities — New York, Baltimore, St. Louis, Providence, R.I., and Brattleboro, Vt. — the effort was made to produce engraved adhesives, of which some quantities survive.

An exceptionally nice example of the postmaster’s provisional from Brattleboro, Vt. (Scott 5X1), was offered in the Regency sale, described as very lightly canceled and with a couple of trivial faults. It sold for $8,100, including the 20 percent buyer’s premium the firm adds onto all hammer prices.

A 10¢ St. Louis Bears postmaster’s provisional on greenish paper (Scott 11X2), tied to a large piece of cover front by a red St. Louis datestamp, sold for $12,000.

Connect with Linn’s Stamp News: 

    Sign up for our newsletter
    Like us on Facebook
    Follow us on Twitter

These stamps, which also were issued in denominations of 5¢ and 20¢, are nicknamed “Bears” because of the Missouri coat-of-arms design they depict, and command a premium when they are canceled by a datestamp instead of a pen marking.

Among U.S. stamp issues offered by Regency-Superior was a so-called “premiere gravure” of the 5¢ Jefferson of 1861, a stamp now listed as Scott 67-E9e though described by Regency using its old Scott catalog number, 57.

The premiere gravures were early versions of the issue of 1861 that in some small details differed from the bulk of the issued stamps. Most show a prooflike impression of the design that has led experts to believe they were mostly just that: trial color proofs or essays.

Their classification has proven controversial among dealers and auctioneers. Once listed as regular stamps in the main body of the Scott U.S. Specialized catalog, the premiere gravures were reclassified as essays many years ago, although some stamp professionals nonetheless continue to refer to them by their former catalog numbers.

The 5¢ Jefferson premiere gravure differs from the issued stamp, Scott 67, in lacking tiny leaflets in the corners. The example in the Regency sale, without gum and reperforated on one side, but nevertheless scarce and attractive with excellent, rich color, sold for $12,000.

Among back-of-the-book issues, an 1879 special printing on soft, porous paper of the first 3¢ postage due stamp (Scott J10), was described as being one of just seven sound examples to survive, out of an original quantity of 436. It went for $7,200.

Keep reading our U.S. Auction Roundup:

Looking back at top lots of Harmer-Schau’s APS Stampshow sale

Impressive St. Louis Bears cover realizes $27,600 at Cherrystone sale

Siegel sells award-winning collection of colored cancels